For Seewald's birthday in May 2017, Duggar wrote about their first meeting from her perspective, saying, "I spotted you, the 'new guy,' and our eyes met for a second." Duggar continued, "I had no clue if I'd ever see you again... but you'd be back! Three weeks later, you showed up at our church again, and afterward, my brothers invited you over to our house to hang out for the afternoon and have supper with us."