The Untold Truth Of HGTV's Fixer To Fabulous

We're all about Fixer to Fabulous. While Chip and Joanna Gaines may have shuffled off HGTV as they prepare to launch their own Magnolia Network, viewers have been filling the Fixer Upper-sized void in their hearts with the new series, Fixer to Fabulous. Premiering in the fall of 2019, this new show follows Dave and Jenny Marrs on their mission to revive Arkansas heritage homes to their former splendor.

According to HGTV's press material, the husband-wife team — who are also parents of five — have constructed about 300, custom-built new homes while running Marrs Developing, which "specializes in the renovation and restoration of historic homes in the Northwest Arkansas area." Their differing approaches to the projects they undertake complement each other, with Jenny described as the creative force, and Dave the craftsman and builder.

Since returning with its second season in October 2020, Fixer to Fabulous is attracting new fans with every airing, as more and more viewers check in on the couple's home-renovating antics. Given that the Marrs are relative newcomers to television, there's much about this fascinating pair that viewers may not yet know. Read on to delve into the untold truth of Fixer to Fabulous.

Ahead of the premiere of the second season of HGTV's Fixer to Fabulous, stars Jenny and Dave Marrs teased what fans of the show could look forward to. "As HGTV does, you never go backwards," Dave explained in an interview with Celebrity Page TV. "We're just building on what we did in season one. It's bigger, it's better, it's cooler reveals."

According to Dave, the new season of Fixer to Fabulous also brought additional challenges — such as renovating a lake property — that took the couple out of their comfort zone. "We're in some places we never even thought we could get to," he continued. 

In the midst of it all, added Jenny, the couple are also raising five kids, and she's happy for the "help" that she's receiving. "You can't do it all. You can't do it all alone," she shared. "You need good people around you, and thankfully we have that."

When HGTV first announced it was filming a TV pilot with Dave and Jenny Marrs in Bentonville, Ark., that pilot was not called Fixer to Fabulous. As Arkansas' Talk Business & Politics reported at the time, the pilot was originally titled Almost Home. "Dave and Jenny Marrs are renovating one historic house at a time, until it's almost home!" was the tagline. "This was totally out of the blue for us," Marrs shared in late 2017. "We were proceeding very cautiously... we wanted to make sure the area is shown in a good light."

A few months after the pilot aired, TB&P reported that HGTV had picked up Almost Home, ordering eight one-hour episodes. Taping, Jenny said, would begin in spring 2018 and continue through to the end of the summer. As TB&P pointed out, the show that was later renamed Fixer to Fabulous was one of several new HGTV series set in small towns throughout America. "We're keeping our focus squarely on developing the kind of content that attracts new viewers and encourages them to sample the programming on our networks," said John Feld, HGTV senior vice president for programming.

The series pilot of HGTV's Fixer to Fabulous – then called Almost Home – introduced handyman Chase Looney, who assists Jenny and Dave Marrs on their renovation projects. Hardcore fans may have noticed that in subsequent episodes, Chase is wearing an eyepatch over his left eye, which wasn't the case in the pilot.

As Chase wrote in a post on his now-defunct website (vis Distractify), just a few days after completing the pilot he was igniting a fireworks display to celebrate the Fourth of July. After lighting the last of five mortars, he wrote, the "concussion" from the one he'd lit previously tipped the one he'd just lit. "When the explosion went off, I remember everything stopped," he wrote, recalling "a deafening boom" and "burst of light."

Rushed to a nearby hospital, Chase was told he'd lost his eye and that the scarring on his face might be permanent. He then informed Dave and Jenny. "I told them, 'I don't think I have the face for TV anymore,'" he wrote. "Through tears and laughter they reassured me I never had a face for TV anyway."

While Dave and Jenny Marrs' company, Marrs Developing, renovates existing homes as well as constructs new domiciles, that latter part of their business isn't something that viewers will see on Fixer to Fabulous. That's simply because transforming rundown houses into lovingly-renovated dream homes makes for better television than a new build. 

As Jenny told At Home in Arkansas, both she and her husband have a real affinity for older homes. "Historic homes were built with such care and attention to detail," she explained. "The builders focused on using all available space and local resources to build these homes." She added that each home has its own unique character, unlike new homes that are built to be cost-effective, thereby lacking real charm.

As for how they come up with the designs they utilize for their Fixer to Fabulous renovations, Jenny says their esthetic inspiration comes from such eclectic sources as modern European design and traditional New England homes. "I would say our personal style is a touch Scandinavian with elements of California Coastal," she continued. "[We're] very focused on natural light and beautiful spaces that are functional for modern families."

Dave and Jenny Marrs hadn't had any experience in front of the camera when they were tapped to film the pilot for Fixer to Fabulous. As Jenny admitted in an interview with the Arkansas Democrat Gazette, having a camera crew following them around took some getting used to — especially when it came to the couple's five children. "When they film with the kids, that's always unpredictable," she revealed. She added that she tends to forget that she's wearing a microphone, too.

Jenny recalled one awkward moment when they were asked film a scene where they walk out of the door. What should have been a simple shot was complicated by the children, as "somebody was always crying. I said, 'You guys! All I need is five minutes! Just act like normal people, OK?' And then I was like, 'Oh, you can hear all of that, can't you? Well, now you know.'"

However, as they got more accustomed to being filmed, Dave said he forgets there's a crew at all. "I think you just get used to it after a while," he told About You.

As viewers of Fixer to Fabulous have certainly witnessed, the projects that Dave and Jenny Marrs take on for the show are certainly not without their obstacles. 

Discussing their experiences filming the first season, Jenny told Almost You that the biggest challenge they faced had to do with the strict timeframes imposed due to the demands of television. "It was really tight, just because of the production schedule," she revealed. "We had a few weeks, for the most part, from start to finish, and if something did go wrong..."

That, Jenny said, proved to be the case when an item needed to complete a renovation was cracked when it arrived. "We were in trouble because we didn't have enough time to get another one," she continued. " And that happens often, whether it's lights or tile or if we find something in the house that we have to completely redo." Given their time constraints, Dave and Jenny often have to get creative at the last minute.