The Best And Worst Disney Channel Original Movies Of All Time

We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Disney Channel Original Movies aren't the blockbuster films the Walt Disney Company is best known for. After all, Disney is popular for its prolific film making, with a long and extensive history covering everything from revolutionary animated classics like Snow White and the Seven Dwarves to live-action adventures like Pirates of the Caribbean. But Disney's TV movies — for better or for worse — are in a category all their own.

Some of these Disney Channel Original Movies, or DCOMs, are excellent, enjoyed by children and adults alike with surprisingly great acting, high production values, and good stories. Meanwhile, other Disney Channel movies simply don't work, enduring bad casting, poor writing, and often a few too many awkward dance numbers.

Here are some of the best and worst Disney Channel Original Movies. Some have impressed audiences of all ages, while others have made viewers wonder how the films got made in the first place.

Disney Channel has been known to make movies out of their most popular shows, and, generally, they're successful. There was the popular The Even Stevens Movie in 2003, plus blockbuster films like 2009's Hannah Montana: The Movie, which made a gross profit of over $155 million worldwide.

But Disney Channel really missed the mark with Kim Possible in 2019. First of all, the original TV show aired from 2002 to 2007, which means the Disney Channel Original Movie aired 12 years after the show ended. This is a problem because, by 2019, Kim Possible's original fans had likely aged out of Disney Channel altogether. Plus, the choice to make Kim Possible a live-action movie instead of a cartoon forced the style, humor, and action to go in a different direction, losing much of the charm of the animated series. The movie came and went, impressing few.

While High School Musical may have been a big hit back in 2006, the sequels of the musical sensation weren't all so... sensational. There was 2007's High School Musical 2 and 2008's High School Musical 3: Senior Year, which, weren't nearly as successful as the original, with fewer catchy songs and less charm than the first movie. Still, at least the second and third films featured most of the same actors, avoiding cringe-worthy recasting. But when Sharpay's Fabulous Adventure premiered in 2011, it was missing most of the cast and their characters from the original.

The film follows Sharpay's solo adventure moving to New York City, but, without Troy, Gabriella, and the rest of the gang, the story falls flat. The song and dance numbers struggle compared to the original High School Musical and viewers are somehow supposed to root for a character who played the antagonist in the original. The Disney Channel Original Movie wasn't well received, earning just a 43 percent from viewers on Rotten Tomatoes.

When it comes to musical movies, Disney Channel has come out with plenty. There was High School Musical, the Descendants franchise, and, of course, 2003's The Cheetah Girls. This film, which followed a singing and dancing girl group, may not have been one of Disney Channel's finest, scoring only a 4.8 out of 10 on IMDb, but it was a fun flick with lots of pre-teen-approved songs. Plus, it had some star power, including Raven-Symoné who played the titular character in That's So Raven.

The Cheetah Girls' popularity carried over to 2006's The Cheetah Girls 2. However, things started to go downhill when Disney made The Cheetah Girls: One World in 2008. For one thing, the Disney Channel Original Movie was missing one pivotal cast member: Raven-Symoné. Plus, it came out five years after the original, meaning many of the original fans likely grew out of watching Disney Channel by then. 

While there are still plenty of entertaining song and dance numbers in the movie with some surprisingly strong choreography, Raven may have taken the best parts of the girl group with her when she left. 

Emily Osment — that's right, Haley Joel Osment's younger sister — made a name for herself when she landed the role of Hannah's best friend Lilly in Hannah Montana. Since then, she's had some other good roles in Young & Hungry, The Kominsky Method, and Almost Family. But just as her Hannah Montana fame was starting to wind down, she signed on to star in 2009's Dadnapped, which clearly was a mistake.

The Disney Channel Original Movie is about a girl, Melissa (Osment), who only wants her father's attention, but her dad is busy with his career, writing spy books. Right before an overdue father-daughter vacation, Melissa's dad is kidnapped and it's up to her to save him. The plot is forced and the acting is just okay. Over all, it's not Disney Channel's proudest moment. The film earned a 4.9 rating on IMDb, and perhaps the only reason it went that high is that fans liked seeing a cast full of popular Disney Channel stars of the time, including as David Henrie of Wizards of Waverly Place fame and Osment's Hannah Montana co-star Jason Earles.

Remakes aren't always bad. In fact, 2003's Freaky Friday, starring Lindsay Lohan and Jamie Lee Curtis, was a box office hit and was perhaps more enjoyable than the original 1976 version starring Barbara Harris and Jodie Foster. The 2003 version scored a respectable 88 percent from critics on Rotten Tomatoes and earned a gross worldwide profit of $160 million, and the original 1976 film earned a 70 percent from critics on Rotten Tomatoes, earning almost $26 million in gross worldwide profit. Not too shabby.

But it turns out that the third time is not the charm for Freaky Friday. When the 2018 musical version hit Disney Channel, it simply didn't have the reception the other two films enjoyed. This Disney Channel Original Movie skipped out on big names like the previous movies and went with relative unknowns Cozi Zuehlsdorff and Heidi Blickenstaff. While going with smaller stars is hardly a bad thing, these two simply didn't deliver quite like the pairs that came before them, leading to this film scoring 66 percent from critics and 22 percent from audiences on Rotten Tomatoes.

Halloweentown was a big success and so were the first two sequels. Halloweentown II: Kalabar's Revenge scored a 6.5 on IMDb and Halloweentown High got a 6.2. All things considered, those are pretty good ratings. And it's no wonder, as the original core cast, Including the late Debbie Reynolds, agreed to return for the two Disney Channel Original Movies. But by the time Return to Halloweentown came out in 2006, the Halloweentown franchise was haunting Disney Channel.

The first big mistake was with casting. While Debbie Reynolds signed on for this fourth film, the original Marnie was replaced. It's not clear why she was recast, but it seems it wasn't actress Kimberly J. Brown's decision (via Seventeen). Still, no matter the reason, the casting change cost the film dearly. Without the spark Brown brought to Marnie's character, the film just wasn't the same.

There's no teen drama movie quite like 2012's Frenemies — and that's not a good thing. The movie is about three sets of friends, who each have some sort of conflict, but they find a way to get along again just in time for the (very awkward) song-and-dance scene at the end.

The film features some of Disney Channel's biggest stars of the time, including Bella Thorne and Zendaya from Shake it Up and Stefanie Scott from A.N.T. Farm, but even a good cast can't cover up the fact that the three separate storylines are predictable with extremely low stakes.

The movie focuses on two girls who battle over a coveted senior editor position, a boy and his dog who suddenly don't get along, and a set of look-a-likes who decide to trade lives for a day. The movie was based off of a book by the same title by Alexa Young, but it seems something was lost in the journey from book to film. The DCOM ended up doing poorly, getting a low 42 percent audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. It's a Disney Channel Original Movie that's best forgotten.