Erika Kirk's Makeup Routine Downgrade Is So Obvious In Unfiltered Throwback Pics

Erika Kirk has undergone quite the transformation from pageant queen to political powerhouse following the death of her husband, conservative activist Charlie Kirk. While she's now the face of Turning Point USA, her actual face — specifically, what she's been putting on it — has been generating its own discourse in social media. In fact, more than a decade ago, when Kirk was fresh off her Miss Arizona run, she understood something that seems to have slipped through all the MAGA makeovers: you don't need to pile it on to make a point.

Throwback photos from Kirk's pageant days reveal a woman who worked with her natural beauty, not against it. Back then, she embraced more subtle, earth-toned eye makeup and dirty-blonde hair that played nicely with her outfits, as in the below photo from May 2012, taken during a twilight cruise off Pier 78 at Hudson River Park when she was Erika Frantzve. Now, she has fully embraced the infamous "Mar-a-Lago face," complemented by heavy lash extensions and dramatic cut-crease eyeshadow. Some have called the aesthetic a Republican uniform of sorts; we call it a downgrade.

Michael Stewart/Getty

If you look at those old photos, one thing becomes positively clear: Kirk once knew the difference between enhancing and embalming. Her mascara application was delicate enough to let her eyes actually breathe, and her foundation matched her skin tone. However, somewhere between 2012 and becoming a golden-haired crusader for her late husband's legacy of campus conservatism, she traded in her perfect polish — glamorous yet approachable — for whatever passes for war paint in MAGA circles these days.

The transformation in Erika Kirk's eye makeup is jarring when you place new and old photos side by side. She kept things restrained back when she was vying for her Miss Arizona crown. Minimal mascara and shadow allowed her pale blue eyes to do the heavy lifting. These days, the dark, aggressive application has become its own spectacle, one that social media sleuths can't help but highlight every time Kirk appears for a public event. Worse still is the cakey foundation. Once applied with a careful hand, she now — for whatever beauty rationale that eludes comprehension — bathes in it.

Kirk's own Instagram account tells the story of this descent into makeup madness. If you scroll through the timeline, you come across many professionally taken photographs that show a woman with traditionally flawless skin who clearly didn't require the armor of foundation she now deploys. In one professional photo from just April 2022, she sits on a stool and smiles naturally at the camera. Her skin looks enviably radiant, and the makeup is so minimal you can actually see her real complexion shining through, which is a far cry from the masklike application she'd adopt in 2025.

Whether Kirk was genuinely drawn to this bolder aesthetic or it's simply the result of her assimilation into a new political environment is anyone's guess, but some of these older photos speak for themselves. Sure, the new look makes a statement, but many people have noticed that something elegant was lost in the translation. The woman who once knew exactly how to let her natural beauty shine has buried it under layers of foundation and an increasingly orange tan. In fact, it turns out you can bury a lot under all that foundation — including good taste.