Every Hallmark Hanukkah Movie (So Far), Ranked By Reviews

Add The List on Google:
Google Discover

If there's one thing the Hallmark Channel is known for, it's a seemingly endless supply of made-for-TV Christmas movies. Hallmark's 2026 "Countdown to Christmas" lineup alone consists of a whopping 34 new holiday movies, the vast majority of which naturally center around Christmas. Every so often, though, the feel-good network shakes things up a bit by adding a Hanukkah movie or two into the mix. The very first Hallmark holiday movie to explicitly feature Hanukkah as part of its narrative was 2012's "Hitched for the Holidays." However, it was radio silent on that front for a while afterwards. Then, in 2019, Hallmark returned with not one, but two more: "Holiday Date" and "Double Holiday."  Ever since, the network has put out at least one new Hanukkah-themed movie every year. 

Granted, they don't always keep Christmas out of the story entirely. In fact, a common theme in these movies is an interfaith couple having to juggle both holidays. At any rate, Hallmark's now-annual Hanukkah tradition continues in 2026 with "Eight Nights for Love," which is slated to premiere on November 29 (making it just one of more than a dozen new holiday releases that month). In the meantime, we decided to take a look back at the Hanukkah-themed movies that have already come out, at the time of this writing, to see how they stack up against each other, according to audience reviews.

10. Leah's Perfect Gift

"Leah's Perfect Gift" stars Emily Arlook as Leah, a Jewish woman excited to celebrate Christmas for the first time with her boyfriend Graham, who's played by heart-stealing Hallmark hunk Evan Roderick. However, when Graham takes Leah home to meet his family, problems quickly arise — not least of which is the fact that his mother, played by Barbara Niven, isn't particularly welcoming to her. The 2024 film holds a weighted average user rating of 6 out of 10 stars on IMDb. It also holds a weighted average rating of 2.86 stars out of 5 on Letterboxd, which gives it an average rating of 5.86 out of 10 stars across both sites.

9. Holiday Date

"Holiday Date" (2019) stars Brittany Bristow as Brooke, a woman whose boyfriend breaks up with her just before the holidays. Desperate for a date to bring home to her family, she hires an actor named Joel, played by Matt Cohen. Brooke initially sells Joel as a Christmas fanatic, only to discover he's actually Jewish. And while Brooke's family is more than happy to incorporate Hanukkah traditions for Joel, the whole "fake dating" thing may not go over as well.

On IMDb, the film holds a weighted average user rating of 6.4 stars. Its weighted average rating on Letterboxd is 2.66 out of 5 stars, which gives the movie a final average rating of 5.86 stars. Despite its rating being tied with "Leah's Perfect Gift," we've rated it one place above. (Don't worry, we'll explain our reasoning for that at the end of the countdown.)

8. Oy to the World!

At the time of this writing, 2025's "Oy to the World!" is the most recent entry in Hallmark's small but growing catalog of Hanukkah movies. Brooke D'Orsay and Jake Epstein lead the charge as Nikki and Jake, a pair of former high-school choir rivals of differing faiths who must work together when their town's Christmas and Hanukkah celebrations end up happening under the same roof. "Oy to the World!" currently holds a weighted average user rating of 6.3 out of 10 stars on IMDb. Its weighted average Letterboxd rating is 2.8 out of 5 stars, with the film's average rating across both sites coming in at 5.95 stars.

7. Love, Lights, Hanukkah!

"Love, Lights, Hanukkah!" features Mia Kirshner as Christina, a restaurant owner preparing for the Christmas season. However, the universe throws her a curveball when a DNA test reveals that she's actually Jewish. While celebrating Hanukkah for the first time, Christina finds herself falling for a man named David, played by Ben Savage. On IMDb, "Love, Lights, Hanukkah!" has a weighted average user rating of 6.8 out of 10 stars. On Letterboxd, it has a weighted average rating of 2.82 out of 5 stars, bringing the 2020 release's combined final average to 6.22 stars.

6. Hitched for the Holidays

In addition to being the very first Hallmark movie to prominently feature Hanukkah, 2012's "Hitched for the Holidays" also effectively created the blueprint for many of the feel-good network's subsequent Hanukkah-themed releases. The film stars Joey Lawrence and Emily Hampshire as Rob and Julie — a Catholic man and a Jewish woman, respectively — who pretend to be a couple to keep their families happy during the holidays. Naturally, they end up catching feelings for real before all is said and done. "Hitched for the Holidays" has a weighted average user rating of 6.6 stars on IMDb and a weighted average rating of 2.97 out of 5 stars on Letterboxd. Its average across both sites is therefore 6.27 stars.

5. Hanukkah on the Rocks

The first film on this list to not really involve Christmas in any significant capacity, 2024's "Hanukkah on the Rocks" stars Stacey Farber as Tory, a corporate lawyer who loses her job right before Hanukkah. She accepts a bartending gig at a local watering hole and falls for a visiting doctor named Jay, played by Daren Kagasoff, during the Hanukkah festivities. On IMDb, "Hanukkah on the Rocks" has a weighted average user rating of 6.9 stars, while over on Letterboxd it has a weighted average rating of 2.92 out of 5 stars. In the end, its average across both sites comes out to 6.37 stars.

4. Double Holiday

"Double Holiday" centers on corporate employee Rebecca, played by Carly Pope, whose Hanukkah plans are upended when she's forced to plan the company's Christmas party with her office rival, Chris, played by Kristoffer Polaha. However, as the two spend more time together, and Chris gets to experience some of Rebecca's Hanukkah traditions, they slowly realize they may not be so different after all. "Double Holiday" premiered on the Hallmark Channel in 2019 alongside "Holiday Date." Between the two, however, this film evidently did a better job winning over audiences. It currently holds a weighted average user rating of 6.8 stars on IMDb, as well as a weighted average rating of 3.01 out of 5 stars on Letterboxd. The movie's average across the two sites sits at 6.41 as a result. 

3. Eight Gifts of Hanukkah

"Eight Gifts of Hanukkah" (2021) stars "Lucifer" alum Inbar Lavi opposite Jake Epstein, of "Oy to the World!" fame. The film follows Sara, an optometrist played by Lavi, who tries to identify the secret admirer who's been sending her anonymous Hanukkah presents every night of the celebrations. On IMDb, "Eight Gifts of Hanukkah" has a weighted average user rating of 6.9 stars. On Letterboxd, it has a weighted average rating of 3.13 out of 5 stars, giving the film a final average of 6.58 stars between the two sites.

2. Hanukkah on Rye

Alexa, play "Matchmaker," because a matchmaker is precisely how Molly and Jacob — Yael Grobglas and Jeremy Jordan, respectively — first find each other in the 2022 Hallmark TV movie "Hanukkah on Rye" (which, by the way, is directed by none other than former "21 Jump Street" star Peter DeLuise). However, their budding romance turns contentious when Molly and Jacob realize that they own competing delis. "Hanukkah on Rye" has a weighted average user rating of 7.2 stars on IMDB, as well as a weighted average rating of 2.99 out of 5 stars on Letterboxd. Its combined average comes out to 6.59 stars, which narrowly secures the movie an impressive second-place finish.

1. Round and Round

"Round and Round" puts a Hanukkah spin (pun intended) on "Groundhog Day." The film features Vic Michaelis, who gets stuck in a time loop on the night of her parents' Hanukkah party. Her only hope of breaking free may just be Zach, played by Bryan Greenberg, a guest her grandmother has been trying to fix her up with. With a weighted average user rating of 7.1 stars on IMDb and a weighted average rating of 3.41 of 5 stars on Letterboxd, 2023's "Round and Round" decisively claims the number one spot with a final average of 6.96 out of 10 stars.

How we ranked the Hallmark Hanukkah movies

To determine the placement of each film, we first looked to each movie's weighted average user score on IMDb, followed by its weighted average score on Letterboxd. We excluded all Rotten Tomatoes reviews, as many of the films were not reviewed enough to generate approval ratings. Next, we averaged each movie's IMDb score and Letterboxd score. As Letterboxd uses a 5-star scale (unlike IMDb, which uses 10), we converted each Letterboxd score to a 10-star scale.

In the case of a tie — like "Leah's Perfect Gift" and "Holiday Date" — we looked at each film's unweighted average rating on IMDb. Ultimately, this enabled "Holiday Date" to break the tie and come away with the first-place spot with a factor of 0.6 points.

Recommended