Revlon Mascara Ranked Worst To Best

As promised, we'll start with the worst. Revlon's Mega Multiplier Mascara ($8.99) is the weakest link out of the bunch, with a thin wand that won't do much for adding length or fullness. While the brand says this mascara is all about "mega thick, mega long" lashes, creating tube structures that wrap around each lash like a falsie, that's not necessarily the case. Sure, we're intrigued by the supposed "oversized lash look," but reviewers assure us this product isn't so amazing.

Although this mascara promises a false lashes-style look, one Amazon reviewer says that this is "no longer a tubing mascara" as it once was, changing its formulation to a "regular, non-waterproof" option that slips down the undereye area. Others agree that this "disappointing" mascara changed for the worse, with one reviewer saying that this is now "a very wet formula" that leads to tons of "smudging" and "globs" around the upper and under eye area. Even making their eyes go "bloodshot," other buyers also noted some irritation. But it's not all bad: One reviewer says this is a "decent, affordable mascara," and another says that while the formula has changed, they're still a "fan" of it and love that it doesn't flake much. The reviews on Revlon's website are a bit better, saying that this "amazing" product is their "new go-to" that comes off quickly with just warm water. Still, it's important to note this is not the mascara to wear for pool days!

Unbelievably enough, Revlon's Ultimate All-in-One Mascara ($8.99) is a six-in-one mascara that promises to deliver just about every eyelash wish in existence. This mascara's new formula supposedly goes the extra mile, injecting lashes with "major volume," separation, lift, darkened color, length, and even some deep conditioning. However, while many reviewers agree this is the perfect formula for "lusher" lashes, it's not all rainbows and butterflies.

The Amazon reviews for this mascara show a slight improvement at 4.5 stars with hundreds of ratings, loving both the brown and black shades, and the option to stick to waterproof. While it's no secret that we love a thick mascara wand, and even though this brush is as tiny as can be, reviewers still applaud it for its true "high impact" benefits. Coined a "Mini Powder Brush," the shape is tailor-made to lengthen even the shortest individual lashes, with a hole in the center that holds onto dollops of the formula. Reviewers write about being surprised at the "no flaking" since the silicone brush has no bristles. Another says this is their "new favorite mascara" that never bleeds, while still coming off easily with makeup remover. Others say this is the mascara to buy if you want thick lashes that look like falsies and is a go-to product for a separated, maximum-length look. Still, the reviews on Revlon's website are a bit worse, saying it "ends up clumpy" once the night is over.

Revlon's So Fierce! Big Bad Lash Mascara ($9.49) is a luxe product in drugstore makeup form. This mascara brings it, and is described as the brand's "biggest, baddest" option yet. If you want magnified volume that creates fluttery lashes you can see from a mile away, you need this product. Even cooler? It injects lashes with a special lash tint that makes them naturally darker after just seven days, so you look ah-mazing even when not wearing mascara. Lash lift, who? This formula promises no smudging and maximum fullness, but does it deliver?

Rounding out at almost 2,000 reviews with 4.3 stars on the Revlon website, it's safe to say this is becoming one of the brand's most popular mascaras. One reviewer writes that the "duality" of the two-sided wand is amazing, using one side for fullness and the other for length. Another says this is their new "go-to" since it makes "lashes look long, lifted, voluminous, yet very natural and soft" with just a couple of swipes. Some reviewers were shocked at the price versus quality, saying it is "very pigmented and long lasting," akin to expensive formulas like It Cosmetics' Superhero Mascara. Buyers can't get enough of the thick, fluffy wand, saying it "hugs the eyes and gives them a thicker, bolder appearance." As per Amazon reviewers, it "actually makes lashes look longer and thicker," adding long-lasting volume and a dose of lash moisture with no flakes.

Remember our love for fluffy mascara wands that elongate lashes from root to tip with tons of volume? That's where Revlon's Volumazing Mascara ($8.99) really hits the mark. It sets itself apart from competitors with its thick, feathery "Turn It Up brush" that leads to "major volume" and eyelashes that would make Snuffleupagus from Sesame Street blush (yeah, lash goals). As per the brand, this wand has signature waves that hold onto individual lashes, coating them to perfection. Use this mascara to achieve 100% volumized lashes that stay separated and never clump, fluttering out at the sides as falsies do. According to Revlon, this won't run down the undereye area, and studies show that 92% of users reported more volume and length. So what do the reviews say?

Surprisingly enough, the reviews for this mascara are generally just as good as its promises, with almost 1,000 4.5-average ratings saying it has a "good brush," and stays on "through sweat and activity without flaking or running." Delivering a "plumping" effect to each lash, buyers say it is not clumpy, has a "nice, deep black color," and even makes "stubby, sparse lashes" look long and thick. Some reviewers comment on how gorgeous the metallic purple tube looks in their makeup bag, and how they've switched out their more expensive "holy grail" mascaras for this one. As per the ratings, just a couple of swipes are enough when using this mascara, so it will last you several months.

And last, we've arrived at the best mascara from the brand's lineup: Revlon's So Fierce! Mascara ($8.99), which is an eye-makeup powerhouse. This will inject lashes with "over the top" length and volume because why settle for just one? This extends lashes past the point of no return while still defining them and keeping the entire situation free of telltale clumps. Incredibly enough, this mascara's wand features a whopping 252 textured bristles (yes, we're amazed, too) that hold onto lashes and take them to the next level (via Revlon). Your lashes will get an actual proper coat of mascara starting at the roots, creating multi-dimensional volume. Even better, it lasts up to 24 hours, so you can feel free partying with this on, and even injects eyelashes with moisturizing rice-bran wax, polymers, and paraffin.

The reviews for this mascara on Revlon's website are unbeatable at 4.6 stars with more than 4,500 ratings, describing the product as "easy to apply," with "dramatic" results and absolutely no irritation. One reviewer says it looks like they're wearing "false lashes" after swiping this on and love how "full and long" they look with zero "clumpage." Dubbed "the best mascara" Revlon has released in a "long time," buyers say the brush is jaw-droppingly effective and makes for a "very natural" look that is still lengthening and volumizing. Other reviewers comment on the effective two-sided brush for fanning out lashes and lifting in equal proportions, with "minimal run-off" even after long nights.