We Finally Know Why These Actors Left The Yellowstone Franchise

Add The List on Google:
Google Discover

In 2018, "Yellowstone" first hit the small screen and it wasn't long before it spawned the spinoffs "1883," "1923," "Marshals," and "Dutton Ranch." And as the franchise continues to grow, so does the list of actors who are a part of the franchise... and so does the list of actors who have parted ways with the franchise. 

Fans have become attached to a number of the characters from the "Yellowstone" universe, and certain actors' departures from the franchise have been met with disappointment, questions, and probably a few tears. Heck, even some of the franchise's actors have been bummed to see certain costars bow out — especially when said decision upends the series. When asked by the The Times in 2026 about how another lead actor's decision to leave "Yellowstone" played a big part in the flagship show's conclusion, Kelly Reilly said, "A lot went on behind the scenes that had nothing to do with me; I was just waiting. 'When are we going back to work?' It was a shame it ended that way, but it did." (Don't worry, there will be more on this in a moment.)

While there are some actors who have not only stayed put on the original series for as long as possible, but went on to follow those characters on a sequel show (looking at you, "Dutton Ranch" stars Kelly Reilly and Cole Hauser), there are other actors who stepped away from the franchise entirely for one reason or another. And yes, some of those reasons are rather messy. Saddle up, because we're about to get into the behind-the-scenes details regarding why some "Yellowstone" franchise characters rode into the sunset. 

Kevin Costner left Yellowstone for new horizons

On a 2026 episode of "The Bill Simmons Podcast," "Yellowstone" creator Taylor Sheridan shared that the initial plan was for series star Kevin Costner to be in just the first three seasons. However, the network didn't want to lose the A-lister, so John Dutton stuck around for another season and a half. "Finally, Kevin hit a point where he said, 'I gotta do my own thing,'" Sheridan said. 

When Costner announced his exit, there was a lot of speculation about whether or not he and Sheridan clashed behind the scenes. Speaking to The Hollywood Reporter in 2023, series creator Taylor Sheridan reflected on Costner's departure in Season 5B. "I'm disappointed," he admitted. "It truncates the closure of his character. It doesn't alter it, but it truncates it." He denied that he and Costner were at odds. "I've never had an issue with Kevin that he and I couldn't work out on the phone," he said, but then added that things did get a little strained once contract disputes and legal teams were thrown into the mix. Costner addressed his controversial "Yellowstone" exit in a 2024 interview with The Hollywood Reporter. "It was a necessary decision to say, 'Hey, OK, I don't want to really talk about this anymore. It's time to move on," he said.

In a 2024 interview with Deadline, Costner explained that he tried to work on his film "Horizon: An American Saga" in between filming for "Yellowstone," but questions about his work ethic and dedication to the show started to make the rumor rounds. And according to Costner, neither the series creator nor the network put said questions to bed. "That's really f***ing bothered me, that none of them would actually try to set the record straight," Costner told GQ.

Kelsey Asbille never made it into Marshals because of scheduling conflicts

Kelsey Asbille, who portrayed Monica Dutton on "Yellowstone," was expected to star in "Marshals." Only, her character died before it could start. In the first episode of the spinoff, viewers learn that she'd died of cancer, leaving behind her husband, Kayce Dutton (Luke Grimes) and their child. "Marshals" showrunner Spencer Hudnut told The Hollywood Reporter in 2026 that he and the writers didn't originally plan to kill off the character. On the contrary, that decision was made because Asbille couldn't commit to filming "Marshals" due to scheduling conflicts.

The writers needed to find a new story arc for Kayce, and his wife's death was certainly one way to do that. "It wasn't like Luke and I were sitting there saying, 'We should kill Monica.' It was more like, 'If she's not available for this, then what's the best way to move on from that character in the least exploitive way?'" Hudnut told the publication. As he said in a separate interview with USA Today, "In 'Yellowstone,' Kayce and Monica had such a happy ending. We needed to turn his world upside down."

Asbille didn't comment on her departure, but Grimes told TV Insider in 2026 that he was the one who told her what Hudnut's plans for her character were in "Marshals." He admitted to being pretty devastated by the news himself. "I was heartbroken for myself and for [Kelsey]. It felt like, 'I don't even know what that would look like doing it without her, what that would feel like," he told the outlet. Asbille took the news about her character's fate well. "She handled it like a pro and totally understood," Grimes shared. Despite no longer working together, Grimes and Asbille's real-life relationship seems to be intact.

Dawn Olivieri's exit wasn't by choice, and was all thanks to Kevin Costner's departure

Dawn Olivieri's "Yellowstone" character, the ruthless Sarah Atwood, orchestrated John Dutton's murder. Sarah was killed a few episodes later, but she wasn't initially set to meet her end the way she did. "I believe I was meant to go into the next season and continue on as a character," Olivieri told The Hollywood Reporter in 2024. "So I think, because of the situation, everything got changed around. The storyline had to go full throttle to figure out how to tie up every end and move things along."

The "situation" she referred to, of course, was Kevin Costner's shocking mid-season exit. Though she mentioned that she was pretty certain Taylor Sheridan didn't initially plan for Sarah to die at that point in the series, Olivieri said she was happy that her character went out with a bang, adding that she's incredibly thankful to have had the opportunity to portray the role. She did, however, admit that she would have loved to see Sarah's story keep going so her relationship with Jamie Dutton could develop into something more. "They could have been an insane powerful couple, who would have been very scary to be working up against!" she noted.

Olivieri, who also played Claire Dutton in two episodes of "1883," is still working in Hollywood — though she's technically called Arkansas home for years. "I realized [Los Angeles] wasn't giving me what my dream of what it was supposed to give me," she told Fox News in 2026. In 2022, she bought a ranch in Arkansas, which she has since turned into a horse sanctuary.

Hugh Dillon's character was written out of Yellowstone so he could work on another show

While there might've been drama surrounding Kevin Costner's exit from "Yellowstone," the way things played out for Hugh Dillon is a different story. Dillon's character, Sheriff Donnie Haskell, was killed off in Season 4 because Dillon's show "Mayor of Kingstown" got the green light to start filming. Dillon not only wrote the script for the "Mayor of Kingstown" pilot with Taylor Sheridan, but Sheridan told Dillon to go ahead and start working on the new show. "[Sheridan said], 'I want you to come and finish work on 'Yellowstone,' but you're going on to 'Mayor.' I've written you an honorable death, and you need to nail this scene," Dillon recalled during a 2023 interview with TV Insider.

"Mayor of Kingstown" had been in the works for a decade before it got picked up by Paramount+. Sheridan cast Dillon as the sheriff in "Yellowstone" while he waited to see whether the show would get a chance to come to life on screen. Dillion told Comicbook.com in 2023 that it all happened very fast. "Mayor of Kingstown" finally got picked up, and he had to head to Texas immediately. "[I] drove to Texas, we wrote the rest of 'Mayor,' and we shot that death scene for 'Yellowstone,' and then I was producing and it's just been a blur ever since," Dillon shared. 

In addition to co-creating the show, Dillon is also one of the stars, producers, and writers on
"Mayor of Kingstown." In 2027, Season 5 will hit Paramount+. Hey, it seems getting killed off of "Yellowstone" panned out for him after all.

Dave Annable wanted to be in Yellowstone for the long haul

Dave Annable's appearance in "Yellowstone" was brief. He played Lee Dutton in the pilot episode, John Dutton's eldest — and favorite — son. He also died in that very same episode. Like many of the actors who left the franchise, Annable's departure wasn't by choice — his character simply didn't survive. But he admitted in a 2024 interview with Life & Style that he wished with all his heart that he could have been a part of the series longer. "I mean, I did [know I was going to die]," Annable admitted. "But I didn't know how much fun I'd have, like going to cowboy camp. I was like, wait a second, I don't want to die. This is amazing."

Annable almost didn't go for the part. He told The Hollywood Reporter in 2018 that there was another project he was eying, and Taylor Sheridan called him up when he heard he was considering turning down the role. "He called back and was like, 'What are you an idiot? You need to come out here.' So of course, I listened," he shared. Despite getting killed off in the first episode, Annable got to make a few more appearances in later episodes for flashback scenes. He told The Hollywood Reporter that he hoped this would happen and he'd get the chance to make a brief return or two.

Annable went on to work with Sheridan again, starring in "Lioness" as Dr. Neal McNamara. He told TV Insider that working with the acclaimed producer again was a dream come true. "To get the call, there's no greater compliment for an actor to have somebody like Taylor call you and ask to work with you again," Annable said.

Josh Lucas reportedly didn't return to Yellowstone because of Kevin Costner's exit

Taylor Sheridan might have attempted to shut down the "Yellowstone" rumor mill with the truth about Kevin Costner's exit, but squashing rumors didn't mean the show could go on as planned after John Dutton's departure. For one thing, it impacted some other characters' storylines in a major way.  Speaking to Deadline in 2022, Josh Lucas, who played a younger version of John Dutton in flashbacks, revealed that Taylor Sheridan told him that he'd have his moment in Season 5 as there were plans to flesh out young John Dutton's storyline. "Taylor told me back before we started shooting the first little pieces that it's not gonna be much for me in the first couple years," Lucas recalled. But when Costner left the show, Lucas' time on the show was cut short, too.

Lucas expressed his regret about not getting the chance to be in more episodes in earlier seasons during his Deadline interview. "I felt sad that I wasn't a bigger part of it — not because of the success. It was more because that I wanted to be part of 'Yellowstone' from the beginning," he admitted.

Ahead of season 5B and the contention surrounding Costner's exit, Lucas told "The Spotlight with Jessica Shaw" that he was cautiously optimistic about getting to return to the second half of the final season despite John Dutton's death. Sheridan indicated there would be more flashback scenes, but Lucas correctly predicted he would not make a return. "I texted [Sheridan] and said, 'You know, I really just wanna thank you for the experience,' because I sort of had assumed it was over with based on, you know, what I think we're all hearing and assuming," Lucas said.

Denim Richards didn't want to leave Yellowstone

Denim Richards' character's death came as a shock to "Yellowstone" fans. As season 5B took viewers on a relentless rollercoaster, ranch hand Colby Mayfield met his untimely end. He was trampled by a horse as he tried to save Carter (Finn Little). Colby gets trampled, and succumbs to his injuries.

The reason for Colby's death? To ground the ranch work featured in the series in reality. As episode director Christina Voros told The Hollywood Reporter in 2024, it was about showing the dangers of cowboy life. "For anyone who really understands the lifestyle of cowboys and working with animals and the risks ... it's a dangerous job, and this kind of thing happens and it happens in a split-second," Voros explained. "This death comes as a shock because it's so simple, and it's so grounded in the world in which all these characters work that it's profoundly tragic, because there's no enemy here."

Richards was pretty bummed when he learned his character's fate. "I'm sad to be killed, it feels fulfilling to know that it was impactful. That people actually cared about it," he told The Hollywood Reporter in 2024. He noted that, while he was obviously sad to be leaving the show, he did recognize that, as an actor, his job is to serve the story, and Colby's death certainly did that. Speaking to Entertainment Weekly in 2024, Richards echoed Voros' sentiments. "I feel like this season, Taylor [Sheridan] is really emphasizing the realities of cowboy life," Richards reasoned. "These things do happen, so I do think that there's that element where I think it is about really wanting to emphasize that this is a reality."

Jai Courtney wasn't ready to part ways with Dutton Ranch

Jai Courtney, who portrayed the role of Rob-Will Jackson in "Dutton Ranch," a super popular "Yellowstone" spinoff. However, he didn't make it out of the first season alive. Rob-Will is one of the season's main villains, and he dies after presumably getting shot by Joaquin, his adopted brother, in the Season 1 finale.

Speaking with Men's Journal before his exit, Courtney expressed how thrilled he was to be a part of "Dutton Ranch." "The writing is so much fun in this world, and I think there's huge potential for Rob-Will. We'll see where the creative side wants to take this," he shared. Alas, his character wouldn't make it to Season 2. In a 2026 interview with Esquire, Courtney made it clear that he wasn't ready to leave "Dutton Ranch" when he did. "I was bummed to peel out, because I was having such a good time making the show," he said. Courtney admitted that while he didn't see the death coming, he recognizes it's all for the sake of the story the show's trying to tell. 

Juan Pablo Raba, who plays Joaquin, told Variety that he believes his character didn't shoot Rob-Will. "I'm not being cheeky here. I don't think he did it!" he said, adding that, in his opinion, the timeline in the story doesn't really line up with when the murder occurs, and that Joaquin's motivation to kill his brother is questionable at best. "He's not drunk. He's not drugged. And why? Because a guy, his dad, that honestly he has to hate in so many ways, asked? I think there's a lot of questions to be answered," Raba said. We'll just have to wait and see how it all shakes out in Season 2.

Recommended