Christian Siriano's Most Polarizing Outfits That Divided Fashion Critics And Fans Alike

Add The List on Google:
Google Discover

Christian Siriano and his iconic designs are unforgettable; from Billy Porter's velvet tuxedo gown at the 2019 Vanity Fair Oscar Party to Janelle Monáe's Picasso-inspired look at the 2019 Met Gala, Siriano knows how to create an outfit that steals the show. While his fashion can stun and delight, it has also divided fans around the world. Some love his showstopping looks, and some don't.

Siriano has had a remarkable transformation from an aspiring fashion designer to a red carpet mainstay. He got his start on "Project Runway," winning Season 4 in 2007 as the youngest winner ever at the green age of 22. He went on to launch his eponymous label, Christian Siriano, in 2008 and quickly became famous for his commitment to inclusivity and diversity in fashion. 

Adding to that, Siriano has also built a reputation as a kind, committed designer who sees all people as worthy of dressing well. Famously, in 2016, Leslie Jones jumped on X (then Twitter) to say that no designer would dress her for the premiere of "Ghostbusters." Siriano replied with a waving hand emoji, and the rest is history. Jones walked the premiere in a stunning red Siriano gown with a thigh-high slit and an off-the-shoulder neckline, looking stunning. While Siriano is a fashion world darling and a designer who frequently steals the red carpet, some of his most iconic looks have been pretty polarizing, and people often disagree about his more prominent red carpet designs. 

Billy Porter's velvet tuxedo gown got wildly mixed reviews

Billy Porter wore a custom Christian Siriano tuxedo gown to the 2019 Vanity Fair Oscar Party on February 24, 2019, in Beverly Hills, California. The look ranked high on the list of Porter's best-dressed moments, and it's obvious why. "If we were going to do a tuxedo, it can't just be a tuxedo," Siriano told E! Insider that night. "It needed to be a moment." Siriano also shocked fans by admitting that he made Porter's outfit in one week because that was all the time they had.

Fashion fans were outright obsessed. "The top is Cary Grant, the bottom is Audrey Hepburn, and the ensemble is downright gorgeous. Love it!" one enthusiast wrote on YouTube. "Best outfit of the night," another commented. However, Porter's black tuxedo gown was divisive, and other folks had mixed feelings about the look. "I am a fan of Christian Siriano.....next time send Billy Porter to TOM FORD," someone wrote. Ouch. "Weird, just weird!" another chimed in, clearly not loving Porter's look. Another kept it short. "[N]o," was the only comment. So, not everyone loved it. 

Celine Dion's blue dress with a giant bow caught flak as well as praise

Celine Dion arrived at the Los Angeles Premiere of "Beauty and the Beast" on March 2, 2017, in Los Angeles, wearing a baby-blue Christian Siriano gown from his pre-fall 2017 collection. Fans raved about the unique gown. "And that powder blue frock that you're wearing will live forever!" a fashionista commented on YouTube. "Celine is to music what you are to fashion- one of a kind!"another wrote to Siriano on Instagram of this specific look. "Sorry but can you pick my jaw up off the floor?" another chimed in. 

While some loved the look, others weren't so sure of Siriano's design. The cornflower blue was a problem for some. "Gorgeous cut and fit but the color is so pale that it almost washes her out!" one person wrote on Instagram. Another thought the big bow was too much. "What is that thing on her shoulder? omg it looks like Celine Dion [is] carrying her towel," another wrote on X with disapproval. Fashion Bomb Daily couldn't decide on Dion's blue gown, giving an ambivalent headline of: "Hot! or Hmm... Celine Dion's Beauty and the Beast Premiere Christian Siriano Pre-Fall 2017 Gown." Clearly, Dion's dress wasn't a universal hit.

Janelle Monáe's Picasso-inspired color-blocked outfit had people in a tizzy

Janelle Monáe stunned at the 2019 Met Gala on May 6, 2019, following the theme, Camp: Notes on Fashion, perfectly in a custom Christian Siriano look. The outfit, a surreal, Picasso-inspired concoction, featured an oversized hat, a color-blocked skirt, and an eye on her chest. In the stunning transformation of Monáe, this look comes as a key fashion moment. Vanity Fair praised the look, claiming that Siriano hit "all the high notes" with Monáe's playful ensemble. Harper's Bazaar loved Siriano's design for Monáe, saying the "look was major." Meanwhile, Teen Vogue praised the fit because of how well it adhered to the theme that year.

While major fashion outlets raved about Siriano's design, others didn't feel quite as impressed. "So lame," someone wrote of the look on Facebook. "The whole ensemble kind of disturbs me,"another wrote on the Reddit group r/ProjectRunway. "It's weird as hell. Just saying. I don't get it," a third added on Facebook. Obviously, the look wasn't for everyone.

Sarah Jessica Parker in black and gray plaid was a controversial choice

Sarah Jessica Parker wore a Christian Siriano gown in black with a silver plaid design when she attended the 2025 PEN America Literary Gala at the American Museum of Natural History on May 15, 2025, in New York City. The gown wasn't an immediate hit. The blog Tom & Lorenzo stated that the dress was a fail because it looked too heavy for a spring gala and would have been better suited for a holiday event. Plus, they claimed the tiered skirting looked off. Others felt similarly. "Love her fashion choices.. not sure about this one," someone else wrote on Instagram of the look. "Sorry it's a miss," another person added.

The dress was divisive enough, though, that others disagreed. "Amazing dress! So unique," a dissenter chimed in on Instagram. "Stunning dress, stunning woman!"another commented. "That is so understated but beautiful. Honestly, one of her best looks,"someone else wrote. People just couldn't agree about this Siriano creation.

Christina Hendricks' blue dress was both loved and roasted

People couldn't quite agree about the blue and white floral gown that Christian Siriano designed for Christina Hendricks' rehearsal dinner before her wedding to George Bianchini in New Orleans in April 2024. On Reddit, people liked the mermaid gown with oversized sleeves, but many couldn't get past the print. "...it looks like [Siriano] attacked a 1790s New Orleans chaise lounge and curtain set and put [Hendricks] in it," someone wrote on Reddit while still admitting that Hendricks looked good. "My first thought was curtains! Or wallpaper," another wrote of the Siriano gown. Meanwhile, someone else said, in a nice way,that Hendricks looked like a vase. Okay then.

But for everyone else, the gown was a huge hit. People loved the bold structure, particularly how great it looked on Hendricks. In fact, her and Siriano's relationship is epic amongst netizens. "As someone with a large chest and wide hips, I consistently love how he knows how to dress a woman with curves. If I were famous I'd love to work with him. I love when he dresses Christina Hendricks," a fan raved on Reddit. People raved about how gorgeous she looked andhow Siriano is a master at dressing women for their shape. 

Lizzo's 2020 Billboard Music Awards dress was a controversial look

Lizzo wore a custom black one-sleeve minidress by Christian Siriano at the 2020 Billboard Music Awards on October 14, 2020, with the word "VOTE" all over it. People were so impressed by the bold dress. "I was so excited when I saw her dress and knew it was yours. Fabulous idea you both had! Love it!" a fan wrote on Siriano's Instagram post about Lizzo's dress. "Love this dress and love [Lizzo]," another commented. "You have yet to disappoint," a third wrote to Siriano. Style Caster dubbed Lizzo the "best dressed" of the night. 

But there was negative feedback, too. "Horrible," someone commented on Siriano's Instagram post about the event. "Lizzo's dress is ugly. Don't let your bias cloud your judgement," another critic commented on YouTube. "Okayyyy all of the dresses are ugly," anothercommented on YouTube on a roundup of looks from the 2020 Billboard Music Awards, and that list included Lizzo's look. Clearly, the "VOTE" dress was pretty polarizing. 

People were mixed about Melissa McCarthy's 2023 Oscars gown

Melissa McCarthy wore a bold red Christian Siriano gown to the Academy Awards on March 12, 2023, in Los Angeles. The gown featured a voluminous tulle skirt with a turtleneck top and long puffed sleeves. The dress landed her on the worst-dressed list for the event on several different online outlets and didn't impress fans. "Wasn't a fan of this unfortunately. Top part to me is too heavy and she lost her neck," one person commented on Siriano's Instagram post about it. "UGG-LEE," another commented. "Just too much material?" a third asked, trying to make sense of the gown's volume.

For others, however, this red Siriano moment was one more great example of McCarthy's stunning transformation. "You make women look beautifully powerful!" a fan wrote, countering the naysayers on social media. Meanwhile, countless others praised Siriano's design, claiming that McCarthy was an undeniable standout at the Academy Awards.

Halle Berry's 2025 Oscars gown was deemed both iconic and impractical

Halle Berry arrived at the Academy Awards on March 2, 2025, in a form-fitting gown covered in over 7,000 hand-applied mirrored sequins by Christian Siriano. For some, the dress was overkill. "It hurts my eyes man too much bling," one unhappy viewer shared on Instagram. Others claimed the gown was impractical. "Can she sit [in] that?" someoneasked on X. For the naysayers, the dress was excessive and unserviceable. 

While some derided the gown, everyone else seemed absolutely crazy about it, praising both Berry and Siriano. "[S]tunning! Christian always makes the right choice for the individual bravo to all the stylists involved with her look," a fan of the look shared on X. "Christian CANNOT LOSE!! I will rewatch is season of Project Runway any day!" another said of Berry's Oscars outfit, also on X. "Halle Berry was The Best Dressed at the Oscars," a third posted, praising Siriano's design.

Janelle Monáe dazzled at the Met Gala in 2026 in a green sci-fi dress

Janelle Monáe wore a bold Christian Siriano creation to the 2026 Met Gala with the theme "Fashion Is Art" on May 4, 2026. The mossy dress was a theatrical ensemble made up of wires, 3D butterflies, and pieces of circuit boards. While the gown was certainly daring, some people didn't jive with the look. InStyle noted that Monáe could hardly walk that night. On Reddit, some didn't connect with the outfit. "I don't get it? Is it cyberpunk with astroturf?" someone wrote on the groupr/whatthefrockk. "[It's] more exciting than most of the looks last night but it just not doing it for me. Too bulky," another wrote on Reddit.

But others absolutely loved it. Harlem Fashion Row claimed that while some interpret the Met Gala's theme, Monáe became the thesis of the night. On Reddit, others hailed Siriano's early days on Project Runway. "[U]nconventional materials challenge made it to the [M]et [G]ala," they joked, praising Monáe's look. Others praised both Siriano and Monáe for taking fashion risks, claiming that it paid off in a huge way that night. 

Harvey Guillen shocked and delighted in Christian Siriano in 2023

Harvey Guillen attended the Academy Awards on March 12, 2023, in Los Angeles, wearing Christian Siriano's first plus-size men's red carpet ensemble. Vogue praised the outfit, claiming that it was a creative take on a classic tuxedo. Guillen himself claimed to E! News (via "Today"). that he was "making history" with his sumptuous outfit, while Siriano himself spoke about his love for the look he created. "I think there is a little bit of that swish and femininity to something of wearing a skirt or a gown at the Oscars that he also wanted — that masculine/feminine play — and, you know, I love ... to do that in my work," Siriano told E! News.

But folks were divided about Guillen's unconventional tuxedo. "This is a horrible outfit," one person wrote rather bluntly on Instagram."Power to him for wearing a garbage bag," another chimed in. "This is what we're calling fashion nowadays?" a third asked. Ouch. 

Lili Reinhart's floral gown at the Met Gala in 2021 garnered mixed feelings

Christian Siriano created Lili Reinhart's floral gown for the 2021 Met Gala with the theme of "In America: A Lexicon of Fashion" on September 13, 2021, in New York City. The gown was very creative; it featured every state flower from all 50 states in the U.S. Bravo called the gown "breathtaking," while Just Jared praised Siriano for actually having fun with the theme. 

While the look was unique, it didn't strike a chord with everyone. "Not my favorite from him but it's okay. The Met Gala was full of bad fashion this year it seemed!" a Redditor wrote of Reinhart's dress on the group r/ProjectRunway. "Looks like a failed crafts project, sorry Christian," another chimed in, unhappy with the Met Gala look. "Out of all the flowing floral heavy dresses at the Met Gala, his was the weakest," someone else wrote, underwhelmed. 

Whoopi Goldberg's 2025 Oscars gown was delightful and divisive

Whoopi Goldberg attended the Oscars on March 2, 2025, in a voluminous, off-the-shoulder ballgown featuring a reflective, liquid-like finish by Christian Siriano. Some liked the look. "I am a fan of Siriano and thought the liquid metallic dress was so cool," an enthusiastic viewer shared on the Reddit group r/whatthefrockk. "I love a) liquid organza, every single time, and b) that Christian Siriano cares about making clothes that fit correctly on women who aren't a sample size," another wrote, praising Siriano's design. "2025 Oscars has to be one of my favorite Christian Siriano garments of all time. The fabric has always made a lasting impression on me. She looked phenomenal and most importantly, confident and comfortable," a third noted. 

Others credited Siriano's skill while remaining critical. "I really don't like Christian Siriano's designs almost every time I see them, but I like what they stand for and Whoopi will always look amazing no matter what or who she is wearing," another Redditor wrote. "She looks like a distress signal," another wrote, rather harshly. "The fabrics are way too stiff and heavy for her imo," a third added. 

Allison Janney wowed in a shocker of a dress at the Las Culturistas Culture Awards in 2025

Allison Janney attended the Las Culturistas Culture Awards on July 17, 2025, in Los Angeles, wearing a pantless Christian Siriano outfit that included a black bodysuit, an asymmetrical suit jacket with a train, and black pumps. People loved the daring outfit. "THIS LOOK IS ICONIC," someone raved on TikTok. "Statuesque and stunning. She knows how to wear that look and not just anyone could pull that off!" another praised the fit. "Holy wow! The styling, the glam and hair are just perfection on her. STUN-NING!" a third added. Janney proved that she was one of the older celebs who flaunted their killer legs and defied Hollywood norms. So powerful. 

Others thought the outfit was too risqué. "Having now seen the tone of the event I think I truly understand the outfit more," someone explained on Instagram, clearly bewildered by it at first. "I love her! hate that damn dress though," another wrote on TikTok. Another made a jab at Siriano. "[S]tylists just be making these celebrities dress like this to entertain themselves," they wrote on TikTok. Ouch. 

Michelle Obama's blue dress got a big reaction

Michelle Obama wore a blue Christian Siriano dress at the Democratic National Convention on July 25, 2016, in Philadelphia. The dress was a big deal. The New York Times noted that this was only the second time that Obama wore Siriano. The first time had been only the month before, when she wore a black dress by Siriano. It was intentional on Obama's part. She was invested in highlighting up-and-coming American designers, which Siriano was back in 2016. People loved it. Action News 5 called Obama's look "flawless." ABC7 cited the blue dress as one of Obama's most memorable looks as first lady. When Siriano posted a close-up of the blue fabric on X to celebrate the moment, fans were all over it. "Michelle looked absolutely fantastic – you did her proud," someone tweeted. 

But dressing a political figure is always a polarizing event. The event made Siriano a darling of the Democratic Party, and as a response, some Republicans have turned away from the designer. But whatever partisan censure it cost him, it seemed worth it for Siriano because he went on to dress Kamala Harris and Jill Biden, too. Fashion and politics can be polarizing, but the collaboration with Obama was undeniably a win for Siriano. 

People disagreed about Jennifer Lopez's red minidress by Christian Siriano

Jennifer Lopez stepped out in a red minidress by Christian Siriano when she received the People's Icon Award at the 2020 E! People's Choice Awards on November 15, 2020. The dress was polarizing; for some, it was so horrendous it counted as one of Lopez's outfits that completely missed the mark. On YouTube, people had comments. "I Love You So Much JLO, But Hate The Dress," a netizen commented. "Her fashion has been off latley [sic] from that huge present bow dress to now dressing like [Kool-Aid] man," another added. "[Yes,] I thought it was just me. I thought the dress looked like a red parachute," a third responded. 

Meanwhile, others defended Lopez's bold, red dress. "I disagree. The dress was beautiful and appropriate for the occasion. [A] piece of art," one fan argued. Meanwhile, Marie Claire called the red dress "flawless," while Vogue praised the dress as a stunning example of holiday dressing. People just had to agree to disagree. 

Recommended