10 Of Our Favorite Paul Campbell Hallmark Movies

When you think of wholesome entertainment, the Hallmark Channel immediately comes to mind. Over the decades, it has captivated viewers with relatable themes like romance, family values, and second chances. As one of the network's beloved leading men, Paul Campbell has won over Hallmark fans around the world, not just as a charismatic actor but also as a talented writer and producer. Speaking to "Crown the Halls" in 2025 about his interactions with admirers, he said, "Hearing stories about how people's lives have been impacted by the movies that we make is really special to us because it gives a lot of meaning to what we do." So, let's look back at some of Campbell's biggest hits over the years.

Born in 1979 in Vancouver, Canada, Campbell has been married to Lorie Metz since 2009. They welcomed a son, Kingston Thomas, in 2016 and lead very private lives. His commitment to discretion hasn't stopped him from gushing about his wife on social media, though — in true Hallmark fashion. On their 10^th wedding anniversary, Campbell shared a photo of the couple riding a bicycle on Instagram, writing, "Life is at its best when both people are peddling, but if one person lags or needs a little help, the other person is there to carry them forward. @lulujeans — you've always carried me forward, and there's no one I'd rather ride off into the sunset with." Without further ado, here are 10 movies where Campbell made us equally swoon, listed in chronological order.

Starring Paul Campbell as Jake Dooley and Chyler Leigh as Sloan Van Doren, "Window Wonderland" was nominated for three Leo Awards, including best direction in a TV movie. The plot follows two employees with completely different visions who compete for the same window dresser position at a Manhattan department store. "It's still one of my favorite movies," Campbell told TV Insider in 2023. "There's something so magical about the script. It was my first Hallmark movie. It was so funny. And I just remember feeling so free to be as silly as I wanted to be. I found my home with that one."

Viewers certainly seem to agree, having become diehard fans of the actor ever since. "Paul Campbell is a Hallmark treasure," one Reddit user dubbed him. Other fans share their appreciation for Campbell's undeniable charisma along with his character's goofiness and humor, especially when he delivered memorable lines like, "I wouldn't be sitting here today if it weren't for ... this chair." Critics rooted for all the characters, enjoyed the witty dialogue and creative storefront dressings, and were pleasantly surprised by the twist at the end. As one fan concluded on IMDb, "If I ever met a guy who made me laugh half as much as Paul does during this movie ... I'd probably marry him."

"Surprised by Love" featured Hilarie Burton Morgan as Josie Mayfield, a driven executive who worked at her father's cookware company, and Paul Campbell as Maxwell Gridley, her carefree high-school sweetheart. The Hallmark project nabbed best musical score in a television movie at the 2015 Leo Awards. In 2023, an amused and nostalgic Campbell recalling how joyful and fun production was from start to finish, telling TV Insider, "I always think of the driftwood scene, building driftwood on the beach, like what a goofball that guy was ... I just got to be silly and ridiculous."

Indeed, this film is hilarious and can easily be considered one of Hallmark's best non-Christmas releases, thanks to the natural performances, relatable family dynamics, and great chemistry between the romantic leads. Plus, the story covers different age groups. "'Surprised By Love' is a charming movie about true love, not only for the young," Dove.org wrote in a review. "Little events happen that show even the older couple how to get back to the love they once had."

"A Godwink Christmas" starred Paul Campbell as inn owner Gery Conover and Kimberley Sustad as Paula Mayer, an antique appraiser. The project earned each of them a nomination for best lead performance in a TV movie at the Leo Awards. Sustad and Campbell have collaborated on several Hallmark movies, not just as romantic leads but also as gifted scriptwriters. This was the production that first brought them together, prompting Campbell to describe that period of his life as a turning point. "'Godwink' was the first really sentimental movie that I did," he told TV Insider in 2023. "And it was completely different from everything else that I'd done. It was where Kimberley Sustad and I met and it started the writing portion of my career. So, that movie was pivotal in that sense."

Because of their special connection and frequent collaborations, the dynamic pair's chemistry in this release (and frankly, in all others) is through the roof. Plus, this film stays true to the holiday spirit and showcases charming Nantucket during that magical period. That said, we wouldn't mind seeing Campbell team up with Hallmark Christmas queen Lacey Chabert in the near future.

"The Last Bridesmaid" tells the tale of Becca, played by Rachel Boston, who forms an unexpected connection with Kyle (Paul Campbell), the wedding videographer hired by her cousin. Campbell, who had never portrayed a camera professional before, was ecstatic during production. As he told TV Insider, "It was great. That was also really, really well written. We shot it in Victoria on Vancouver Island. Beautiful scenic locations. Just a lot of fun."

For the most part, this release was praised for seamlessly blending romance, humor, and tearful moments, not to mention highlighting those equally exciting and stressful stages of wedding planning. The rest of the cast delivered solid performances as well, keeping viewers entertained with their side plots. "The film balances wedding chaos with real personal growth, and by the end, it delivers the payoff every Hallmark fan hopes for. Warm, witty, and genuinely sweet," a viewer concluded on IMDb.

"Christmas by Starlight" isn't just one of the best Hallmark movies to watch during the holidays but also a testament to how comfortable Paul Campbell is wearing dual hats for the network. "It was the first time for me as writer and actor, and I felt drunk with power," he joked to TV Insider. "I loved having control of the dialogue. I loved being able to fix the script as we discovered issues along the way, or if we had to make changes because of certain production issues." The plot centers on William Holt (Campbell), the heir apparent of a Chicago firm, who teams up with lawyer Annie Park (Kimberley Sustad) to stop the demolition of her family's café.

Beyond the generic storyline and sparkling holiday decorations, the movie delivers character development, heartwarming moments, and compelling dialogue reminiscent of the Hollywood Golden Age. "I genuinely laughed a handful of times, and though you could see what was coming plot-wise, it warmed this cynic's heart," a charmed viewer chimed in on IMDb.

"Wedding Every Weekend" was a standout summer 2020 release. It stars Kimberley Sustad as physical therapist Brooke Etheridge and Paul Campbell as vintage car expert and restorer Nate Thomas. When these two characters realize they're invited to the same weddings several weekends in a row, they decide to team up and go as each other's dates to avoid sitting at the singles' table — not to mention facing potential setups from their friends.

In typical Hallmark fashion, Brooke and Nate end up falling for each other. As per usual, the playful and engaging dynamic between Sustad and Campbell was the main selling point. "When those two are in the same movie, you automatically know it's going to be good!" a fan wrote on Facebook. "Campbell, though not your cookie-cutter Hallmark leading man, acts with the 'common everyday man' charm and sophistication that his role requires," another viewer noted on IMDb.

Not every franchise hits the mark, but Hallmark pulled it off with its "Three Wise Men" trilogy. The first installment, "Three Wise Men and a Baby," is Paul Campbell's favorite Hallmark movie. While on set, Campbell predicted this film would become successful, if only for the chemistry between the male leads: Tyler Hynes, Andrew Walker, and himself as Taylor, Luke, and Stephan Brenner, respectively. The three brothers live with their mother, Barbara, wonderfully portrayed by Margaret Colin. Although estranged, the brothers reconnect when they're suddenly forced to take care of Thomas, an abandoned baby.

Co-written by Campbell and Kimberley Sustad, this first part of the trilogy won best screenwriting in a television movie at the Leo Awards and was nominated for both best TV movie and best direction. It was the most watched feature of 2022 on cable, according to the Nielsen ratings. "That was one of the best filming experiences in my life, getting to spend three weeks with those boys," Campbell recalled to TV Insider in 2023, adding, "Kim and I wrote what we thought was such a fun, full of heart, silly movie ... It will always be very, very close to my heart." According to Campbell, the mood during production was so enjoyable it led to a lot of adlibbed lines. Viewers agreed that the bickering trio was a lot of fun to watch, especially when they danced to the Nutcracker's Sugar Plum Fairy.

In "Three Wiser Men and a Boy," the Brenner brothers come together for Thomas' holiday recital at school. The adorable 5-year-old boy was played by Miles Marthaller, who earned best performance in a TV movie at the Young Artist Awards for his role. Dubbed even more entertaining than the first installment, this sequel enchanted viewers with its goofiness, dance routines, and character development. It was commended for its relatable family issues as well as Tyler Hynes, Andrew Walker, and Paul Campbell's stellar performances.

"It showcases what it means to be a human and flawed. It also showcases the importance of family and how to be accepting of change in our lives," a user wrote on IMDb. Some reviewers on that platform found the interactions between Stephan (Campbell) and his girlfriend Susie (Fiona Vroom) endearing, while others dubbed this equally festive and touching release the ultimate family-friendly watch.

"Three Wisest Men," the third part of Hallmark's "Three Wise Men" trilogy, earned Paul Campbell and Kimberley Sustad a nomination for best screenwriting in a television movie at the Leo Awards. It was also nominated in the best costume design category. In November 2025, co-scriptwriter Russell Hainline shared on Letterboxd, "It's been a dream getting to work on a franchise filled with lovely people and loved by so many ... Overall, it's very difficult writing something this dense with characters and storylines — I hope everyone who liked it checks out the extended cut."

In this installment, Taylor considers a job offer in another state as Luke awaits the birth of his twins and Stephan plans his wedding. Adding to the stress, their mother Barbara lists the family home for sale. "Paul Campbell is fun as he puts Stephan's neuroses on full display," a reviewer wrote for Hotchka, noting the character's personal growth across all three films. Overall, fans praised the intelligent writing and high production value, recommending this timeless Hallmark gem to viewers of all ages.

If you're a feline lover who also enjoys Paul Campbell's Hallmark movies, then we recommend you watch "Christmas at the Catnip Café." In this release, the beloved Canadian actor wears scrubs to play Dr. Ben Kane, a veterinarian who also co-owns a café that welcomes stray cats. Played by Erin Cahill, the character Olivia Pierce inherits the other half of the café from her late great-aunt, but she plans to sell it before Christmas in order to afford a condo.

Speaking to Popternative in 2025, Campbell recalled, "I kind of just had zero expectations, and in this case, I was really, really, blown away by the production value, by the sets, by everything." For his part, Ian Collins, who played the barista Frank, told TV Fanatic, "Paul was also really funny on set and super, super intelligent. He writes these movies. He knows how the flow is supposed to go ... We all really tried to make that familiar, warm feeling on set, which is the feeling that, ideally, everybody gets when they're watching this at home." Although the human performers and their compelling interactions were widely praised, it was the furballs that captured everyone's hearts, which was no easy feat considering how difficult and disruptive these animals can be on set.