Hallmark Holiday Movie Couples With Crackling Chemistry

Add The List on Google:
Google Discover

If there's one thing that can take a Hallmark holiday movie to the next level, it is the chemistry between the romantic leads. Of course, not all Hallmark movie couples are created equal; just take a look at the best Hallmark Christmas movie couples according to fans. And while some Hallmark movie couples are actually played by real-life lovers and may seem to have an advantage in the chemistry department, we should also give some proverbial flowers (or mistletoe, in this case) to the casting department for assembling onscreen couples who bring the heat once the camera starts rolling.

Take the quick connection that happened between "Mistletoe Murders" stars Sarah Drew and Peter Mooney, for example. "It's hard to find chemistry over Zoom, but we managed to do it that day," said the latter when speaking to Parade. "We found it. Something about this has just kind of clicked from the beginning. It felt familiar and comfortable and safe and trusting." Interestingly, even in the almost mathematically formulaic holiday movies that Hallmark makes, there's still no equation or simple sum for getting great screen chem. The couples either have it or they don't. With that in mind, let's take a look at the most palpable chemistry between couples in their holiday movies.

Alison Sweeney and Marc Blucas are so good together in Good Morning Christmas

When a member of a Hallmark movie fan page on Facebook asked their fellow Hallmarkistas which screen couples in the broadcaster's oeuvre had the most chemistry, more than one fan named Alison Sweeney and Marc Blucas. If their festive flick "Good Morning Christmas" is anything to go by, they're right.

In the 2020 film, former footballer Brian Bright (Blucas) and broadcasting lifer Melissa Merry (Sweeney) have an AM show together on TV and travel to a small town to host a series over the festive period. There, despite their signature squabbling, they fall in love. "This is the second film these two have made together and they have a lot of chemistry in both," wrote one fan of the film on Reddit. "[L]oved their banter and chemistry," added a user on the movie review site Letterboxd. "I loved the town of Mistletoe that gave us all the Christmas feels. Marc Blucas is my favorite Alison Sweeney co-star. They just work well together!" If this winter romance doesn't convince you of the pair's chemistry, then they've also gained piles of plaudits for their connection in 2016's "The Irresistible Blueberry Farm."

One criticism of this film? Well,it's certainly not about the chemistry. Rather, it's about the title of the TV series within the movie. "[I] literally hate that the show name is 'bright and merry' and not 'merry and bright' and i cannot let it go," wrote another user on Letterboxd. Oh, Hallmark.

Emily and Henry deliver the Hallmark charm in Love at the Thanksgiving Day Parade

There's nothing worse than forced chemistry. Indeed, like confidence or kindness, chemistry cannot be faked. It's one of those things in life that's easier to see through than melted snow. Thankfully, then, don't just have Hallmark Christmas movies, but Thanksgiving ones too, that show us what great chem looks like. 

Heck, Autumn Resser's Emily and Antonio Cupo's Henry, from 2016's "Love at the Thanksgiving Day Parade," are more in tune than the marching band on New York's famed Macy's walk. Their film, which is set in Chicago, sees city native parade organizer Emily and financial consultant Henry feud about the Thanksgiving parade, fall for each other, and choose between work or romance. It's pretty classic Hallmark stuff. So, what makes their relationship so good? Well, even while unattached, they have the rat-a-tat banter of two old friends while being able to be vulnerable with each other. 

"The chemistry, the writing, the comedy was not forced," wrote one user on Reddit. "[C]ompared to some of the newer movies I've seen over the past few years this 'classic' movie really exceeded expectations." As another user responded, "Autumn and Antonio have mad chemistry, especially in this movie." This Thanksgiving, we're giving thanks to Hallmark for this crackling couple. 

Emily and Jamie's chemistry in An Unexpected Christmas is to be expected

There are a few tell-tale signs that you have chemistry with someone, and the couple from 2021's "An Unexpected Christmas" has all of them. Emily, played by Bethany Joy Lenz, and Tyler Hynes' Jamie start as two exes. But when the former, an advertising agency ace, is sent to Jamie's hometown over the holidays for work, his parents are under the impression the pair are still an item. Cue an elaborate ruse to keep his parents believing.

Between the past lovers' button-pushing play fighting, feeling comfortable enough with each other to share their favorite things, and the sense that these two should naturally be together, they display — pardon the pun — all the hallmarks of a couple with more chemistry than a state-of-the-art science lab. "I think they make the best couple and when you watch," wrote one Hallmark-head on Facebook. "[I]t doesn't even seem like they're acting." Now that's what we talk about when we talk about chemistry. "I agree... an absolute favorite for me," responded another Facebooker. "I watch it a lot! Tyler and Bethany Joy have such a connection," they added. "I wish there was a sequel to this one!" With the chemistry that Emily and Jamie have, we do too. "An Unexpected Christmas 2: An Unexpected Sequel," anyone?

Chris and Rebecca of Double Holiday don't hold back on the chemistry

Although Hallmark is known for its long history of making quintessentially Christmas movies, we'd be remiss not to look at the chemistry between couples in holiday movies that aren't just about Christmas. Take "Double Holiday," for example, an office-based multi-holiday party flick. Office rivals for a promotion, Rebecca (Carly Pope) and Chris (Kristoffer Polaha), are tasked with planning the end-of-year office party at their Manhattan property company. 

Naturally, they slowly fall for each other, and Chris learns more about Hanukkah from Rebecca. But will the aforementioned promotion battle cause a rift between the two and put a damper on their crushes on each other? Well, knowing Hallmark, no it doesn't. The pair get together and throw a Christmas-Hanukkah hybrid celebration for their fellow employees. "I want to create traditions with you," says Rebecca at the end of the film. "I would love nothing more," replies Chris. You better believe the leads' chemistry is off the charts.

"There were several scenes when the Carly Pope character was talking to someone else and the look on the Kristoffer Polaha character's face as he watched was just pure adoration," wrote one user on Facebook. "So much to love. The flirty banter, the bickering which was also flirty and the total chemistry between these two," concurred a user on Letterboxd. "Now that's how to do a Christmas romance movie."

Paul Campbell and Kimberly Sustad could teach a chemistry master class

Longtime collaborators Paul Campbell and Kimberly Sustad are Hallmark veterans. They've got many rom-coms together under their belts and have even co-written scripts for the channel. Heck, with the amount of time they've spent working together, some fans even think the pair are dating.

Their undoubted chemistry is perhaps no clearer than in 2020's "Christmas by Starlight," which the partners-in-Hallmark wrote and starred in. You better believe the chemistry they share in the flick is out of this world. In the film, Sustad plays Annie, a lawyer whose family's cafe's existence is threatened at Christmas. But squash-playing nepo baby and property developer William (Campbell) offers to pay her $2 million if she spends a week working for his father as the legal counsel regarding a project that's over budget. Although they start out all business, there's a real romantic Christmas chemistry here. Perhaps best shown in a thoroughly flirty scene when the pair are choosing a Christmas tree and Annie laughs at William when he slips over into the pines.

But don't just take our word for it. "Two of Hallmark's brightest stars put on a class on chemistry and romance," wrote Escape into Film in their review. "Sustad and Campbell's fingerprints are all over this script."

A waltzing Christmas couple wowed Hallmark fans

"Loved this movie. And they actually had chemistry," wrote a user on Reddit about Avery and Roman from "Christmas Waltz." "I have been disappointed with a lack of chemistry from some of the leads this season," they added. Well, if chemistry is what you're looking for, there'd be absolutely no disappointment if you switched on this Lacey Chabert and Will Kemp-led flick.

When Avery (Chabert) has the rug pulled out from under her and the wedding of her dreams is cancelled, Roman (Kemp), a dance teacher, helps her to dance again... and, of course, they fall for each other. As we've seen with "Dancing With The Stars" partners who dated after the show, hitting the ballroom sure can whip up some romance. In "Christmas Waltz," it's no different, with us getting to see the couple find their connection on the dance floor and while shimmying down the street à la "Singin' in the Rain." "So. Much. Chemistry," wrote the Hallmark for All Seasons blog. "From beginning to end our leads were on point."

But "Christmas Waltz" isn't the only Hallmark movie where these actors' chemistry has been praised. "Lacey and Will have great chemistry," said a Hallmark fan on  Facebook of "Love, Romance, and Chocolate." "[D]efinitely lots of romance and the kisses looked real not like some Hallmark movies," they added.

The leads in Thanksgiving-set Pumpkin Pie Wars sure bring it

"Chemistry of the lead actors was A++++++ ," wrote a Redditor about Casey (Julie Gonzalo) and Sam (Eric Aragon) from Thanksgiving-set "Pumpkin Pie Wars." Yes, they really included that many plus signs. "I'm watching this right now," replied a user under the aforementioned post, who couldn't even wait for the film to note the obvious vibes between the main actors. "The chemistry between the leads is really strong," they added.

"Pumpkin Pie Wars" sees the heirs to dueling bakeries going mano a mano in their small town's baking competition. In classic Hallmark style, these enemies become lovers while chopping pumpkin, competing, and squashing their mother's long-term beef. Thanks to cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, cloves, allspice, and aforementioned chemistry, this movie sure brings the spice. "Their chemistry is great and their interactions genuine," wrote the Hallmark Happiness blog. "Super cute watching them try to hide their friendship and budding love from their mothers." Indeed, it's a connection that can even be seen in the small glances between these star-crossed lovers.

So, maybe cancel that Hinge subscription and get yourself down to your local Thanksgiving pie-making contest. You never know, the love of your life could be there.

Even time travel couldn't come between Megan and Charles in A Timeless Christmas

Contrary to popular belief, Hallmark holiday movies are not always set in small towns. Sometimes, the scope is a little bigger. The 2020 film "A Timeless Christmas," for example, traverses space, time, and two centuries. When the Doctor Who-esque Charles Whitley (played by romantic Hallmark movie regular Ryan Paevey) travels over 100 years into the future to 2020, he finds out his home has been turned into a museum and meets the archive's director, Megan (Erin Cahill). Despite one being a 21st-century millennial and the other an Industrialist, they're meant to be. The plot sounds pretty fanciful, but the chemistry between Charles and Megan is very much real.

"The concept of time travel forces you to suspend disbelief, and that's an easy thing to do when the leads have exquisite chemistry," wrote the Lady Geeks blog. "Megan and Charles have always been destined for each other. Period." If further proof is needed, when asked which Hallmark couples have the most convincing on-screen chemistry, one user on Reddit offered, "Examples include, but are not limited to, 'A Timeless Christmas' with Erin Cahill and Ryan Paevey."

'Tis the Season to be Merry for this Hallmark couple

In "'Tis the Season to be Merry," Rachael Leigh Cook plays Merry, a writer and relationship expert who struggles to find love but lies about having a perfect partner in her books. Travis Van Winkle plays Adam, an aid worker who builds houses abroad and is the brother of Merry's friend-slash-editor. Oh, and Merry and Adam happen to be former flames. 

Merry and Adam both end up in Vermont for Christmas, and wouldn't you know it? They fall for each other (again). In doing so, the pair's chemistry was crackling more than the fire they use to toast s'mores together, and they have as strong a connection as their AirPods in one particularly side-splitting surprise re-meet-cute scene. "Rachael Leigh Cook and Travis Van Winkle were so great together," wrote the blog Hallmark for All Seasons. "It was perfect. Talk about chemistry. Theirs was amazingly good." We can't help but agree.

"[T]he least egregious of the hallmark christmas movies," reads one Letterboxd review damning with faint praise. "[T]he leads have chemistry and personality!" Given that Merry and Adam's connection is enough to convert Hallmark-haters, why not give this one a watch?

In Round and Round, there's a strong vibe between Rachel and Zach

"Oxytocin, known also as the love hormone, provokes feelings of contentment, calmness, and security, which are often associated with mate bonding," wrote Richard Schwartz and Jacqueline Olds for the Harvard Medical School about being lovestruck. If there was ever a time you'd need a feeling of contentment, calmness, and security, it's when you're stuck in a time loop and perpetually attending your parents' Hanukkah party.

That's exactly what happens in 2023's "Round and Round." Thankfully, for the day-repeating Rachel (Vic Michaelis), she had the chemistry with new flame Zach (Bryan Greenberg) that would make that debacle a little easier. Indeed, between quickfire back-and-forth banter, "Groundhog Day" references, and never-ending alarm clocks, these two certainly hit it off. As the loveably nerdy Zach says in the Hallmark rom-com, "If we have to do this 100 more times, I'm here for it."

"I loved the chemistry between Vic Michaelis and Bryan Greenberg," gushed one Redditor of this Hanukkah set holiday movie. "[T]he amazing chemistry and gorgeous banter make the entire thing a fundamental delight," says Hallmark holiday movie aficionado the Lady Geek blog. "The tension between Rachel and Zach is so deliciously enticing and quietly sweet," they add. "The reserved moments and the loud banter make for a love story that's thoughtfully vulnerable and features growth for both parties." Although it might not be your typical Hallmark holiday on display, the top-tier chemistry remains.

Fans still catch feelings for Catch a Christmas Star

Hallmark has released hundreds of holiday movies over the years, so it wouldn't take much for a flick to get lost in the shuffle over the years. Such is not the case for "Catch a Christmas Star." It is a well-remembered Hallmark flick from 2013, in no small part thanks to the chemistry between its two lead love interests.

It's a story of tabloid-courting pop star Nikki reuniting with the high school beau she never quite got over and now dad of two, Chris — played by Shannon Elizabeth and Steve Byers, respectively — while signing copies of her new album. Through a barrage of false press rumors and their differing worldviews, they fall back in love once again. Their chemistry is so powerful it makes it feel like the pair are the only people in a packed arena while Nikki performs her track "Christmas Star" on-stage. 

"This was adorable and if you hate on it it's because you are broken inside," said one hardline Letterboxd user. "I wish Steve Byers and Shannon Elisabeth had done more of these together," they added. "Great chemistry." 

The connection between Mistletoe and Mimosas' Claire and Zach is a treat

"The first day, the first line, I was like, 'Oh, this is gonna be good. I think we naturally had chemistry. We didn't even have to work at anything," said romantic lead Tamera Mowry-Housley when speaking to Parade about Hallmark's 2026 film "Mistletoe and Mimosas." "I think it's because I had a partner that helped elevate [her flirtier and feistier side]," she added. "[Kristoffer Polaha is] passionate about it and cares. Like, he truly cares." That chemistry didn't end on the first day, thankfully. 

In "Mistletoe and Mimosas," Mowry-Housley is Claire, a Manhattanite business consultant who has recently inherited her uncle's bar. Polaha is Zach, the owner and manager of a club that's across the street. And wouldn't you know it, they battle it out over the Christmas season to see who can bring in the most business and, of course, fall head over heels for each other. "[A] great supporting cast and two top-notch lead actors with wonderful chemistry," is Hotchka's review of the cast. Indeed, Claire and Zach's chemistry is so potent, some think it carries the film by itself. "The leads have good chemistry," reads a two-and-a-half-star review on Letterboxd that didn't have many other positive notes.

Mistletoe? Mimosas? And crazily crackling chemistry? That's a heady Hallmark mix you won't want to miss out on.

Recommended